Choosing a Math Curriculum for a Struggling Learner
This page does not rank math curricula. A 2021 federal guide on extra math help recommends six ways of teaching. It rates the evidence for each as strong. In our view, they make a good checklist. The guide's studies were of help given in school, not at home. We hold no study that compares named curricula with each other.
TL;DR
- This page does not rank math curricula. We hold no study that compares named curricula with each other.
- A 2021 federal guide on extra math help recommends six ways of teaching. The guide rates the evidence for each of the six as strong. That grade is for the advice as a whole, not for each step in it.
- In our view, the guide's six make a good checklist for any math curriculum. The checklist questions on this page are ours. No study we hold tests a checklist like this.
- The 2021 guide's studies were of help given in school, not at home. The guide has no study of a parent teaching this way at home.
- If your child hates math, look at how math feels before you switch books. That is our view.
A math curriculum is the planned order of math lessons. It includes the books and materials that go with them.
”Math curriculumIs there a best math curriculum for a child who struggles?
This page does not rank math curricula. We hold no study that compares named curricula with each other. So we do not name a best one.
What we can share is what a federal guide recommends for extra math help. You can check any math book against it.
What does the federal guide recommend?
A US federal guide on extra math help came out in 2021 (Fuchs and colleagues). It covers children who struggle with math, from kindergarten to sixth grade. It is about help in small groups or one to one, at school. In its words, it may help parents "to understand what mathematics assistance might be helpful for their children."
The guide recommends six ways of teaching.
- Step-by-step teaching. Go back over earlier work, and mix it in. Start new ideas with easy numbers. Build each lesson on the last one. Give quick, kind feedback.
- Clear math words. Teach the right words, and use them the same way each time.
- Objects and drawings linked to the numbers. Show the model and the written numbers together. Which model suits which topic is the panel's advice.
- Number lines. Use them to show where numbers sit and how big they are.
- Types of word problems. Teach one type of problem at a time. The guide says to "avoid teaching key words that link specific words to operations."
- Short timed practice. Use it only on facts already taught. The goal is right answers, with progress kept private.
The guide rates the evidence for each of these six as strong. Strong means its studies kept finding gains, across different groups of children. That grade is for the advice as a whole, not for each step in it.
Each study tested a whole package of help. So the guide does not show what one step adds on its own. Nothing in the guide tests Learning Success.
Our pages on number lines and word problems say more.
Questions to ask of any curriculum
These questions are ours, built from the guide's advice. No study we hold tests a checklist like this. Look through a few lessons with them in mind.
- Does it go back over earlier work, and mix it in?
- Does it start each new idea with easy numbers?
- Does each lesson build on the one before?
- Does it teach clear math words, and keep using them?
- Does it show objects or drawings next to the written numbers?
- Does it use a number line?
- Does it teach types of word problems, not key words?
- Is timed practice kept to facts already taught?
- Is that practice about right answers, not how many are tried?
In our view, a curriculum does not need to say these words. Look at what the lessons do.
What the guide does not tell you
The guide has no home studies. The 2021 guide's studies were of help given in school, not at home. The help came alongside class. The guide has no study of a parent teaching this way at home.
No ranking of curricula. We hold no study that compares named home curricula with each other. We use the guide only for what to look for.
Geometry. The 2021 guide found no studies on geometry that met its standards. That is not a finding that geometry teaching does not help.
It is not a guide to dyscalculia. It covers children who struggle with math, or are at risk of it.
It does not isolate one step. Each study tested a whole package of help. So the guide does not show what one step adds on its own.
If your child hates math
In our view, a new book alone is not the answer to hating math. First, look at how math feels to your child.
To us, hating math often goes with work that is too hard. Or the work moves too fast. Worry about math can come along too. Watch where your child gets stuck, and when the upset starts.
The 2021 guide gives advice for a child who gets anxious during timed practice. One idea is to say that finishing is not expected. Another is to use flash cards, not a long sheet. The guide rates the evidence for timed practice as strong. That grade is for the advice as a whole, not for each step in it. Its studies were of help given in school, not at home.
In our view, dread of math needs its own attention. Our page on math anxiety covers it.
If you teach math at home
The 2021 guide's studies were of help given in school, not at home. The help came alongside class, in small groups or one to one.
In our view, a home plan can follow the same six ways of teaching. That is our suggestion, not a tested plan. Use the questions on this page to check what you already have.
In our view, you may not need to switch at all. You can often add what is missing. For example, you can add a number line beside the lessons you have.
When to ask for help
Each of these is a reason to ask for help on its own.
- Little change, even with steady practice and good teaching.
- Math well below your child's other schoolwork.
- A teacher who raises a concern about math.
- Extreme upset about math.
- Complete avoidance of math.
- Worry about math that spreads into the rest of learning.
- Sadness or worry that lasts.
- A skill that was there and has gone. Our position is that a lost skill goes to a doctor first, not a tutor.
If no skill has gone, start with the teacher. Say what you are seeing at home, and what you have tried. Beyond the teacher, the right person depends on what it turns out to be about. If the work is too hard, someone who works on that school skill. If worry or mood is the thing, someone who works with children's mental health. In our view, if you are worried enough to ask, a professional evaluation is worth asking about.
Any talk of hurting themselves is a same-day call to your doctor or a crisis line.
In the classroom
In our view, tell families the math words and tools you use in class.
One sentence for an email home: "We use a number line in class. Could you use one at home too?"
Key Takeaways
This page does not rank math curricula. We hold no study that compares named curricula with each other.
A 2021 federal guide on extra math help names six ways to teach. The guide rates the evidence for each as strong. That grade is for the advice as a whole, not for each step in it.
The list of questions on this page is ours. No study we hold tests a list like this.
The 2021 guide's studies were of help given in school, not at home. Nothing in the guide tests Learning Success.
Our position is that a lost skill goes to a doctor first, not a tutor.
Open your child's math book to this week's lesson. Look for one thing. Does the lesson go back over old work before it starts something new? Make a note of what you find. You are not grading the book. You just want to know it. This routine is ours. It is one thing to notice, not an answer on its own.
”What to do tonightWhat to use next
A set of questions you answer about what you see at home. A screener is a starting point, not a diagnosis. If your child might need formal accommodations (an IEP or 504 plan), or you suspect a vision, hearing, or medical cause, pursue a professional evaluation too — that's the only route to those supports.
What sits underneath arithmetic, one skill at a time, worked alongside math instruction, not in place of it.
A parent course inside All Access on the layer under your child's math: where numbers sit on a line, five and ten as landmarks, breaking numbers apart, and whether an answer makes sense. Five-minute moments with things already in the house. Use it alongside math instruction, not in place of it. The activities are adapted from ones tested mostly with researchers and teachers. How well they work with a parent at the table has barely been studied, and not at all past about age seven. It comes after our parent course, Foundations.
Common questions from parents
What is the best math curriculum for dyscalculia?
This page does not rank math curricula. We hold no study that compares named curricula with each other. A 2021 federal guide on extra math help recommends six ways of teaching. In our view, they show what to look for. The guide covers children who struggle with math, not dyscalculia in particular. Three of the six are teaching step by step, clear math words, and models tied to the numbers. The rest are number lines, types of word problems, and short timed practice. That practice is only for facts already taught. The guide rates the evidence for each as strong. That grade is for the advice as a whole, not for each step in it. Its studies were of help given in school, not at home.
What homeschool math curriculum works for a struggling student?
We hold no study that compares named home curricula with each other. A 2021 federal guide on extra math help recommends six ways of teaching. The guide rates the evidence for each as strong. That grade is for the advice as a whole, not for each step in it. Its studies were of help given in school, not at home. In our view, a home plan can follow the same six. That is our suggestion, not a tested plan.
What math curriculum is good for a kid who hates math?
In our view, a new book alone is not the answer to hating math. To us, hating math often goes with work that is too hard. Or the work moves too fast. Worry about math can come along too. Watch where your child gets stuck, and when the upset starts. In our view, dread of math needs its own attention.
What should I look for in a math curriculum?
A 2021 federal guide on extra math help recommends six ways of teaching. The guide rates the evidence for each as strong. That grade is for the advice as a whole, not for each step in it. Its studies were of help given in school, not at home. From that advice, we ask questions like these. Does it start new ideas with easy numbers? Does it use a number line? Does it teach types of word problems, not key words? These questions are ours. No study we hold tests a checklist like this.
Should I switch my child's math curriculum?
In our view, you may not need to switch at all. Check what you have first. A 2021 federal guide on extra math help recommends six ways of teaching. The guide rates the evidence for each as strong. That grade is for the advice as a whole, not for each step in it. Its studies were of help given in school, not at home. In our view, you can often add what is missing. For example, add a number line beside the lessons you have.