Identity Beyond School: Where Else Competence Can Grow
Apart from one study by White's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests hobbies or sport on how children see themselves. In our view, notice what your child picks when nobody asks. Give that thing real time in the week. Keep some of it just for them. Compare your child to your child.
TL;DR
- Apart from one study by White's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests hobbies or sport on how children see themselves.
- In our view, notice what your child picks when nobody asks. Give that thing real time in the week.
- In our view, keep some of it just for them. Do not make it a prize for schoolwork.
- Compare your child to your child. Not to a brother, a sister or a classmate.
- A large U.S. study followed almost 10,000 children (White and colleagues, 2019). Parents said how often their child did chores early in school. Three years later, children with more frequent chores rated themselves higher. They rated their social skills, school ability and life satisfaction. That shows a link, not a cause. We could read only its summary.
Identity beyond school. As we use the words, this is how your child sees themselves outside schoolwork. It includes what they are good at there.
”Identity beyond schoolThe short answer
Apart from one study by White's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests hobbies or sport on how children see themselves. That is a gap in what we hold, not a finding either way. Use the ideas as you like.
So we cannot tell you what a hobby will do for your child. What this page gives is our way to look for a place to start.
Why look beyond school?
School may be hard for your child right now. In our view, give your child a place to get better at something too.
In our view, the point is not a talent. It is a place to see yourself getting better.
In our view, your child's strengths are their own. Notice what your child is good at. That needs no label. Our page on confidence from evidence has more.
This page makes no claim that a skill outside school carries over to schoolwork.
Where else competence can grow
These ideas are ours. We hold no study that names them.
- Notice what your child picks when nobody asks. Watch a free afternoon. See what they go back to.
- Ask what they are good at. Ask about life outside school. Write down what they say.
- Give it real time in the week. Put it on the calendar.
- Keep some of it just for them. Leave that part with no school attached.
- Let them teach you. Or let them teach a brother or a sister. Let them show how it works.
- Compare your child to your child. Not to a brother, a sister or a classmate.
Schoolwork can also start from an interest. Our page on interest-led learning has more.
What one study of chores found
A large U.S. study followed almost 10,000 children (White and colleagues, 2019). Parents said how often their child did chores early in school. Three years later, children with more frequent chores rated themselves higher. They rated their social skills, school ability and life satisfaction. That shows a link, not a cause. We could read only its summary.
In our view, a job at home is one more place to get better. White's study did not test that. Our page on chores has more.
Keep it out of the homework deal
In our view, do not make the activity a prize for schoolwork. Our page on why motivation disappears has more.
In our view, do not take the activity away to punish bad grades. Keep it in the week, good grades or bad.
A course for the parent's side
Foundations, our parent course in All Access, trains the parent who sits beside the child, one skill a week. We hold no study of the course itself.
When to ask for help
Some children could do something and now cannot. Our position is that a lost skill goes to a doctor first, not a tutor.
If no skill has gone, start with the teacher. Say what you are seeing at home, and what you have tried.
Any talk of hurting themselves is a same-day call to your doctor or a crisis line.
Tonight, ask your child what they are good at outside school. Write down what they say. This idea is ours. We hold no study of it.
”What to do tonightWhat to use next
Our parent course, inside All Access. It trains you, the parent beside your child, in six skills from martial-arts teaching, one a week. Each week has a short video, a small drill for you and one exercise with your child. Your child never watches a video.
Common questions from parents
Will sport or a hobby build my child's confidence?
Apart from one study by White's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests hobbies or sport on how children see themselves. We cannot promise that. In our view, pick it for its own sake. In our view, the point is not a talent. It is a place to see yourself getting better.
My child struggles at school. Where else can they get good at something?
Apart from one study by White's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests hobbies or sport on how children see themselves. In our view, your child's strengths are their own. Notice what your child is good at. That needs no label. In our view, watch what your child picks when nobody asks. Give that thing real time in the week. Compare your child to your child.
Should I take away an activity when grades drop?
Apart from one study by White's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests hobbies or sport on how children see themselves. In our view, no. In our view, do not make the activity a prize for schoolwork. Keep it in the week, good grades or bad.
More in Motivation and confidence
- Confidence Comes From Evidence, Not Encouragement
- Interest-Led Learning: Using the Obsession as the Doorway
- Intrinsic vs Extrinsic Motivation, Honestly
- Should They Tell Their Friends? Disclosure to Peers
- When Other Kids Notice: Teasing, Reading Groups and Being "The Slow One"
- Why Motivation Disappears in a Struggling Learner