Start Free Trial

Writing Stamina: From Two Sentences to Two Paragraphs

To us, writing stamina is how long a child keeps writing before they stop. We hold no study that tests a way to build writing stamina as such. In our view, find out where your child gets stuck. Then build length one sentence at a time. Two paragraphs is a goal to work toward, not a promise or a timeline.

TL;DR

  1. To us, writing stamina is how long a child keeps writing before they stop. In our view, a child who stops after one sentence may be stuck. The sticking point may be letters, spelling, ideas or a plan.
  2. One trial taught handwriting to first graders who found handwriting and writing hard (Graham, Harris and Fink, 2000). They gained more in handwriting than children given lessons on sounds. They also wrote more, and the gains were still there six months later. That was how much they wrote, not how well. We could read only its summary.
  3. A US federal guide for classroom teachers says to give time to write every day. It rates the evidence for that as minimal. The guide says research has not tested whether writing every day beats writing less often. The guide says a minimal rating does not make advice less important.
  4. We hold no study that tests a way to build writing stamina as such. We hold no study of parents teaching writing at home. The home routines on this page are ours.
  5. In our view, plan first, then add one sentence at a time. Two paragraphs is a goal to work toward, not a promise or a timeline.
“

Writing stamina is our name for how long a child keeps writing before they stop. It is not a test score or a diagnosis.

”Writing stamina

Two sentences to two paragraphs: a goal, not a promise

The title of this page is a goal we set at home. It is a goal to work toward, not a promise or a timeline. It is not a norm for any age or grade.

In our view, the useful measure is your child's own last piece of writing. Did one more sentence reach the page this time?

Where the stopping can come from

We cannot tell you why your child stops. In our view, a child can stop after one sentence for more than one reason.

To us, writing their own sentence asks a child for four things at once. They form the letters. They spell the words. They find the sentence. They keep the plan in mind.

To us, letters and spelling that are not yet automatic can take effort away from the ideas. This is one real reason a child writes less than they know. It is not the only one.

In our view, a child may also stop because there is no plan. To us, one idea gets written, and then nothing says what comes next.

Some children start neat, and the writing falls apart after a few lines. To us, that can point to stamina, or to writing not yet automatic. It does not mean they stopped caring.

In our view, the useful question is which parts are hard for your child. A child can have trouble with more than one.

Our page on slow writing has more on where the time can go. Our page on handwriting load and composition load has more on the jobs.

What the research we hold says

A US federal guide on teaching elementary writing came out in 2012 (Graham and colleagues). It was written for classroom teachers, from kindergarten to sixth grade. A panel wrote it.

We read the whole guide. It gives four main pieces of advice. Each one has a grade. The guide does not cover parents teaching writing at home.

Handwriting, spelling and how much children wrote

The guide grades its advice on handwriting, spelling, sentences and typing together. The grade is moderate. That grade is for the advice as a whole, not for each step in it.

Eight of its nine studies on these skills found gains. The gains were on things like spelling, handwriting, sentences and how much children wrote. Some also found no gain, or a loss, on other measures.

In the guide's studies, handwriting and spelling practice helped those skills, but no evidence showed better writing overall. Few of them checked writing overall.

To us, the practice helped the thing it worked on. More writing is not the same as better writing.

The guide says to practice handwriting and spelling in short bits, often. Then the child uses the skill in real sentences. That is the guide's advice for class.

One trial taught handwriting to first graders who found handwriting and writing hard (Graham, Harris and Fink, 2000). They gained more in handwriting than children given lessons on sounds. They also wrote more, and the gains were still there six months later. That was how much they wrote, not how well. We could read only its summary.

To us, that is a gain in how much, not in how good. In our view, watch both at home. How much did they write? How good was it?

Handwriting practice makes handwriting better, but its effect on composing is not settled. In our view, teach composing as well.

Time to write every day

The guide also advises time to write every day. It rates the evidence for that as minimal. The guide says research has not tested whether writing every day beats writing less often. The guide's hour a day in class is the panel's figure, not a tested amount. The guide says a minimal rating does not make advice less important.

The guide still says to write each day. We cannot say it builds stamina. To us, saying so is honest. It does not make the advice wrong.

Planning and typing

The guide rates teaching writing strategies step by step as strong. That grade is for the advice as a whole, not for each step in it. Planning is one of those strategies.

The guide says to teach each strategy in steps. Explain why it helps. Show it, thinking out loud. Practice it together. Then hand it over, and not too early.

Some children find writing very hard because of handwriting or spelling. For them, the guide's panel suggests typing as the main way to write, with extra teaching. That is the panel's advice.

Nothing in the guide tests Learning Success.

What the research we hold does not show

We hold no study that tests a way to build writing stamina as such.

Some studies we hold measured how much children wrote after lessons. Some found more writing. One small trial found no change in length. That is not the same as how long a child keeps going.

We hold no study of parents teaching writing at home.

We give no number for how long a child should be able to write. We hold no study that sets one.

The guide's advice to write every day is rated minimal. To us, it does not tell you that more time builds stamina.

Building up, one sentence at a time

The home routines on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests them at home.

Start where your child is. Count the sentences your child writes now. That is your starting point, not a score.

Say it first. Ask your child to tell you the idea out loud. Then they write it.

Plan in three boxes. Draw three boxes on a page. Put one idea in each, as a word or a picture. Then write one sentence for each box.

Add one sentence. When one sentence feels easy, ask for one more. Then stop.

Keep it short. In our view, stop while it is still going well. Come back to it another day.

Share the load. Let your child say some sentences while you write them down. Or let them type, once typing has been taught. Then bring the handwriting back in. The point is to let a child try the parts one at a time. It is not to take the work away for good.

Count sentences, not minutes. In our view, a timer adds one more thing to watch. Count what reaches the page instead.

From sentences to paragraphs. To us, a paragraph is a few sentences about one idea. Two paragraphs are two ideas, with a few sentences each. Two boxes can become two paragraphs.

Work on handwriting, spelling and composing side by side.

When to ask for help

Each of these is a reason to ask for help on its own.

If no skill has gone, start with the teacher. Say what you are seeing at home, and what you have tried. Beyond the teacher, the right person depends on what it turns out to be about. If the work is too hard, someone who works on that school skill. If worry or mood is the thing, someone who works with children's mental health. In our view, delays in speech, language or movement are worth raising with your child's doctor. In our view, if you are worried enough to ask, a professional evaluation is worth asking about.

Any talk of hurting themselves is a same-day call to your doctor or a crisis line.

In the classroom

1

In our view, count the sentences on the page, not the minutes spent. Note where the writing stops, and tell the family.

2

One sentence for an email home: "He stops after one sentence in class. Could we try planning in three boxes before he writes?"

Key Takeaways

1

To us, writing stamina is how long a child keeps writing before they stop. In our view, a child who stops after one sentence may be stuck. The sticking point may be letters, spelling, ideas or a plan.

2

One trial taught handwriting to first graders who found handwriting and writing hard (Graham, Harris and Fink, 2000). They gained more in handwriting than children given lessons on sounds. They also wrote more, and the gains were still there six months later. That was how much they wrote, not how well. We could read only its summary.

3

We hold no study that tests a way to build writing stamina as such. The home routines on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests them at home.

4

In our view, plan first, then add one sentence at a time. Two paragraphs is a goal to work toward, not a promise or a timeline.

“

This is our routine. Ask your child to tell you about one thing from today. Draw two boxes, one for each idea. Put one idea in each box. Ask for one sentence for each box. Stop when the two sentences are done.

”What to do tonight

What to use next

free

Free resources

Downloads and free programs.

free

Dysgraphia screener

A set of questions you answer about what you see at home. A screener is a starting point, not a diagnosis. If your child might need formal accommodations (an IEP or 504 plan), or you suspect a vision, hearing, or medical cause, pursue a professional evaluation too — that's the only route to those supports.

membership

All Access

Every Learning Success program in one membership.

Common questions from parents

Why does my child stop after one sentence?

We cannot tell you why your child does this. In our view, a child may stop because a job is still hard. That job may be letters, spelling or ideas. Or there may be no plan. Our page on handwriting load and composition load has more.

How do I build my child's writing stamina?

We hold no study that tests a way to build writing stamina as such. The home routines on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests them at home. In our view, start with the sentences your child writes now. Plan the piece out loud first, in three boxes. Then add one sentence at a time. Stop while it is still going well.

Should I use a timer?

In our view, count sentences, not minutes. To us, a timer adds one more thing for your child to watch. In our view, count what reaches the page, and compare it with last time. That is our view, not a finding. We hold no study that tests a way to build writing stamina as such.

Will typing help my child write more?

Some children find writing very hard because of handwriting or spelling. For them, a US federal guide's panel suggests typing as the main way to write, with extra teaching. That is the panel's advice. The guide was written for classroom teachers. One US study had 241 children in grades 2, 4 and 6 (Berninger and colleagues, 2009). They wrote by pen and by keyboard. At every grade, they wrote longer essays, faster, by pen. The authors tie that mostly to how much practice and teaching each way had had. To us, typing will not always mean more writing at first. Typing has to be taught, like handwriting. In our view, teach it before your child has to rely on it. Our page on typing has more.

How long should my child be able to write?

We give no number for this. We hold no study that sets one. In our view, compare your child with their own last piece of writing. Two paragraphs is a goal we set at home. It is a goal to work toward, not a promise or a timeline.

Does writing every day build stamina?

We do not know. That is the honest answer. A US federal guide for classroom teachers advises time to write every day. It rates the evidence for that as minimal. The guide says research has not tested whether writing every day beats writing less often. The guide's hour a day in class is the panel's figure, not a tested amount. The guide says a minimal rating does not make advice less important. We hold no study that tests a way to build writing stamina as such. So we cannot say it builds stamina. In our view, a short try that ends well is a fine place to start.

Start Building Real Skills Today

One membership, every program, no upgrade path.

All Access includes every Learning Success program. You're never one more purchase away from the thing your child needs.

More in Spelling and written expression