Start Free Trial

Retention: Should a Struggling Reader Repeat a Year?

Studies disagree about holding children back. Older studies found it did not help. Better-designed studies found little effect either way. In one large study, gains came when the repeat year included intensive reading help, then faded. None of these studies looked at children with dyslexia or a learning disability. Whatever is decided, ask what will be taught differently next year.

TL;DR

  1. Studies disagree about holding children back a year. Older studies found holding back did not help. Most of those compared groups that were not alike. Better-designed studies found little effect either way.
  2. One large study looked at a Florida reading rule (Schwerdt, West and Winters, 2017). Gains came when the repeat year included intensive reading help. Those gains faded in the years after. The authors could not separate the repeat year from the help.
  3. No retention study we hold looked at children with dyslexia or a learning disability. So these studies do not answer the question for those children.
  4. The studies point to what is taught in the extra year. Whatever is decided, ask what will be taught differently next year.
  5. Whether a child repeats a year is the family's and the school's decision. We give no advice on a particular child.
“

Grade retention means a child repeats a school year. People also call it being held back.

”Grade retention

Should a struggling reader repeat a year?

Studies disagree about holding children back a year. Older studies found holding back did not help. Most of those compared groups that were not alike. Better-designed studies found little effect either way.

One large study looked at a Florida reading rule (Schwerdt, West and Winters, 2017). Gains came when the repeat year included intensive reading help. Those gains faded in the years after. The authors could not separate the repeat year from the help.

The research we hold does not settle it either way. The studies point to what is taught in the extra year.

In our view, the useful question is what will change next year. That holds whether your child repeats the year or moves up.

What did older studies find?

Jimerson reviewed 20 studies in 2001. The studies came out between 1990 and 1999.

Children held back did no better at school than children who moved up. They did no better in how they felt or got along with others.

Most of these studies compared groups that differed in other ways. So the two groups may not have been alike to start with.

Jimerson said the focus should move to the extra help a child actually gets. We read a summary of Jimerson's review, not the paper itself.

What did better-designed studies find?

Allen, Chen, Willson and Hughes reviewed 22 studies in 2009. The studies came out between 1990 and 2007. The authors looked at how well each study was designed.

The effect was "not statistically significantly different from zero" in the better-designed studies. That means no clear harm, and no clear gain.

Any effect shrank in the years after the repeat year.

Many people believe holding back hurts schoolwork. The authors said their results "challenge the widely held view that retention has a negative impact on achievement."

We could read only the summary of Allen and colleagues' review.

What happened with Florida's third-grade reading rule?

Schwerdt, West and Winters studied a Florida reading rule (2017). Under the rule, children reading below the state's standard were held back. This happened at the end of third grade.

They were also given help. They had a summer reading program. They had a highly rated teacher. They had intensive reading every day in the repeat year.

The authors could not separate the repeat year from that help.

The authors found "large positive effects on achievement that fade out entirely when retained students are compared to their same-age peers."

Put simply, gains came when the repeat year included reading help, and those gains faded.

Later, the children held back had higher grades in high school. They took fewer remedial courses there. Those are classes that teach basic skills again.

Being held back had "no effect on their probability of graduating," the authors found.

This study cannot show that the repeat year on its own helps. The reading help came with it.

We could read only summaries of Schwerdt and colleagues' study.

What do the studies point to?

The three studies point in different directions. Even so, two of them point to one thing, in different words.

Repeating the year is not itself the help. What a child is taught in the extra year can make a difference.

Jimerson said to focus on the extra help a child gets. In Florida, the repeat year came with a lot of reading help.

So, whatever is decided, ask what will be taught differently next year.

What did none of these studies look at?

No retention study we hold looked at children with dyslexia or a learning disability. So they do not answer the question for a child with dyslexia. We hold no study of holding back children with dyslexia. That is a gap in what we hold, not a finding either way.

This page is about reading. We hold no study of repeating a year for math alone.

Does your state have a retention rule?

Whether your state has a retention rule, and its exceptions, is not something we hold. Ask the school.

Questions to ask the school

These questions are ours. They are not from a study.

  1. What will be taught differently next year? Ask what will change in the reading teaching.
  2. Who will teach the reading, and how often? Ask for a name and a weekly plan.
  3. How will progress be checked? Ask how often you will hear about it.
  4. What happens with friends and the class? Ask whether your child stays with their group.
  5. If my child moves up, what reading help comes too? Ask the same questions either way.

In our view, write the answers down. Take them to the next meeting.

Who decides?

Whether a child repeats a year is the family's and the school's decision. We give no advice on a particular child.

In our view, a clear reading plan matters either way. Ask for it in writing.

Our page on a summer reading plan has ideas for the break.

When to ask for help

Each of these is a reason to ask for help on its own.

Start with the teacher. Say what you are seeing at home, and what you have tried. Beyond the teacher, the right person depends on what it turns out to be about. If the work is too hard, someone who works on that school skill. If worry or mood is the thing, someone who works with children's mental health. In our view, delays in speech, language or movement are worth raising with your child's doctor. In our view, if you are worried enough to ask, a professional evaluation is worth asking about.

Any talk of hurting themselves is a same-day call to your doctor or a crisis line.

In the classroom

1

In our view, write down the reading plan for next year first.

2

Share that plan with the family before the decision.

3

An email home could say: "Before we decide, can we talk about the reading plan?"

Key Takeaways

1

Studies disagree about holding children back a year. Older studies found holding back did not help. Most of those compared groups that were not alike. Better-designed studies found little effect either way.

2

One study looked at a Florida reading rule (Schwerdt, West and Winters, 2017). Gains came when the repeat year included intensive reading help. Those gains faded in the years after. The authors could not separate the repeat year from the help.

3

No retention study we hold looked at children with dyslexia or a learning disability.

4

The studies point to what is taught in the extra year. Whatever is decided, ask what will be taught differently next year.

5

Whether a child repeats a year is the family's and the school's decision. We give no advice on a particular child.

“

Write down three questions for the school. Start with this one: what will be taught differently next year? Keep the list for your next meeting.

”What to do tonight

What to use next

free

Free resources

Downloads and free programs.

free

Dyslexia screener

A set of questions you answer about what you see at home. A screener is a starting point, not a diagnosis. If your child might need formal accommodations (an IEP or 504 plan), or you suspect a vision, hearing, or medical cause, pursue a professional evaluation too — that's the only route to those supports.

course

The 5-Minute Reading Fix

A short reading and spelling practice. Each word appears letter by letter. The picture comes only once the word is complete. So guessing from the image is not available. It includes writing words from memory. That practices the spelling and the writing of a word at the same time.

membership

All Access

Every Learning Success program in one membership.

Common questions from parents

Should my child repeat a grade for reading?

Studies disagree about holding children back a year. Older studies found holding back did not help. Most of those compared groups that were not alike. Better-designed studies found little effect either way. No retention study we hold looked at children with dyslexia. None looked at a learning disability either. The choice is your family's and the school's. We give no advice on a particular child. Whatever is decided, ask what will be taught differently next year.

Does retention help with reading difficulties?

The retention studies we hold do not settle whether holding back helps. One large study looked at a Florida reading rule. Gains came when the repeat year included intensive reading help. Those gains faded in the years after. The authors could not separate the repeat year from the help. The studies point to what is taught in the extra year.

What happened with third grade reading retention in Florida?

One study looked at a Florida reading rule (Schwerdt, West and Winters, 2017). Children held back under it also got intensive reading help. They had a summer reading program, a highly rated teacher and daily intensive reading. Gains came with that help, and those gains faded. The authors could not separate the repeat year from the help. Being held back had "no effect on their probability of graduating," the authors found. We could read only summaries of Schwerdt and colleagues' study.

Does this research apply to a child with dyslexia?

None of the retention studies we hold looked at children with dyslexia specifically. None looked at children with a learning disability either. So they do not answer the question for your child. That is a gap in what we hold, not a finding either way. In our view, ask what reading help your child will get next year.

What should I ask the school about holding my child back?

These questions are ours. Ask what will be taught differently next year. Ask who will teach the reading, and how often. Ask how progress will be checked, and how you will hear. Ask what happens with friends and the class. If your child moves up, ask what reading help comes too.

Start Building Real Skills Today

One membership, every program, no upgrade path.

All Access includes every Learning Success program. You're never one more purchase away from the thing your child needs.