Algebra Hit Like a Wall
In our view, algebra uses earlier number work in a new way. A national math panel names whole numbers and fractions among algebra's foundations. That is the panel's judgment, not a trial. Our advice: if algebra suddenly gets hard, ask the math teacher which step breaks. If a mastered skill has clearly gone, our position is: doctor first.
TL;DR
- In our view, algebra uses earlier number work in a new way. No study we hold says why algebra gets hard for one child.
- A national math panel names three things algebra is built on. They are whole numbers, fractions, and some parts of shapes and measuring. That is the panel's judgment, not a trial.
- A 2012 study by Siegler and colleagues followed large groups of children. What they knew of fractions and division in elementary school predicted their high school algebra. That is a link, not proof that more fraction work eases algebra for one child.
- A 2015 federal guide on algebra (Star and colleagues) gives three pieces of advice. Study solved problems. Notice how equations are built. Compare ways to solve. Its evidence for comparing ways is moderate. Its evidence for the other two is minimal. The guide is for all students learning algebra, in grades 6 to 12. Nothing in the guide tests Learning Success.
- The home routines on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests them at home. Do them alongside your child's math instruction, not in place of it.
Algebra is math where a letter can stand for a number. In x + 3 = 5, the letter x stands for 2. The two sides of = are the same amount.
”AlgebraWhy is algebra so hard?
In our view, algebra uses earlier number work in a new way. Here is what we mean. These three points are ours.
- Letters stand for numbers. A child has to work with a number they cannot see yet.
- The equal sign means "the same as." Some children read = as "write the answer next." Then 8 = 5 + 3 can look wrong to them.
- Steps come in order. One slip early on can spoil the whole answer.
No study we hold says why algebra gets hard for one child.
What does algebra build on?
A national math panel wrote a report in 2008. It was the National Mathematics Advisory Panel. The report names three things that algebra is built on. Here they are.
- Whole numbers. These are numbers like 7 or 300.
- Fractions. The panel puts decimals and percents in this one too. It also puts in fractions below zero. It says skill with fractions is a base for algebra.
- Some parts of shapes and measuring. The panel calls these geometry and measurement.
That is the panel's view, not a trial. It drew on a survey of algebra teachers. It also used national test results.
What predicts algebra later?
A 2012 study by Siegler and colleagues followed large groups of children. One group was in the US, and one was in the UK. The study looked at what they knew in elementary school. What they knew of fractions and division predicted their high school algebra. It also allowed for other things, like IQ and family income. This is a link between early and later math. It does not show that more fraction work will ease algebra for one child.
My child was fine at math. Why is algebra suddenly hard?
We hold no study of why algebra suddenly gets hard for one child. So here is what we would look at. This list is ours. It is not a test.
- Which step breaks? It may be fractions, or numbers below zero. It may be the equal sign. It may be problems with many steps.
- Is it new work, or a lost skill? Is this math your child had mastered? Has that skill clearly gone?
- What does the teacher see? Ask the math teacher where the work stops making sense.
Our position is that a lost skill goes to a doctor first, not a tutor. If no skill has gone, start with the math teacher.
What does the federal algebra guide say?
One federal guide is about algebra itself. It came out in 2015 (Star and colleagues). It is for grades 6 to 12. It is for all students learning algebra. It is not a guide to dyscalculia. Nothing in the guide tests Learning Success.
The guide gives three pieces of advice.
- Study solved problems. Students look at problems that are already worked out. They talk about the thinking in each one.
- Notice how equations are built. Students look at how the parts of an equation fit together.
- Compare ways to solve. Students solve a problem more than one way. Then they choose a way on purpose.
Its evidence for comparing ways is moderate. Its evidence for the other two is minimal. Here is what each one rests on.
- The advice on solved problems rests on four studies. Three found gains in understanding. One found worse results.
- The advice on how equations are built rests on six studies. They found gains in doing the steps and in understanding.
- The advice on comparing ways rests on six studies. Four found gains.
The guide says comparing works best once a student can do the steps with some ease. Two of the studies on how equations are built included students with learning difficulties. For students in special education, the guide advises clear teaching of why each way works.
What we did not find
Beyond the 2015 guide, we hold no trial of algebra teaching for students with dyscalculia. Some of that guide's studies included students with learning difficulties.
The 2015 guide has no list of skills to learn first. It says skill with arithmetic matters for algebra. It does not say which parts.
These are gaps in what we hold. They are not a finding that help with algebra does not work.
Helping with algebra at home
The home routines on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests them at home. Do them alongside your child's math instruction, not in place of it. The worked examples below are ours too.
Talk through a solved problem. The 2015 guide's advice is to study solved problems. How to do this at home is ours.
- Find a solved problem in your child's book or notes.
- Read it one line at a time.
- At each line, ask, "What changed, and why?"
- Let your child say each step in their own words.
Solve one problem two ways. The 2015 guide says comparing works best once the steps come with some ease. So in our view, use a problem your child can already solve.
- Write 2(x + 3) = 10.
- One way: 2x + 6 = 10. Take 6 from both sides, so 2x = 4. That makes x = 2.
- Another way: split both sides in half. Then x + 3 = 5, so x = 2.
- Ask which way felt easier, and why.
Balance the equal sign with coins.
- Put two plates side by side.
- On the left plate, put 3 coins. Add a cup with some coins hidden under it.
- On the right plate, put 7 coins.
- Say that both plates hold the same amount. Ask how many coins are under the cup.
- Write 3 + x = 7. Lift the cup to check. There are 4.
Check the footing with the teacher.
- Ask the teacher which earlier skills this unit uses.
- Ask about fractions and numbers below zero in particular.
- Practice the ones the teacher names. Our pages on fraction activities and negative numbers have ideas.
- In our view, this is worth doing for its own sake. It is not a promise that algebra will then get easier.
When to ask for help
Each of these is a reason to ask for help on its own.
- Little change, even with steady practice and good teaching.
- Math well below your child's other schoolwork.
- A teacher who raises a concern about math.
- Extreme upset about math.
- Complete avoidance of math.
- Worry about math that spreads into the rest of learning.
- Sadness or worry that lasts.
- A skill that was there and has gone. Our position is that a lost skill goes to a doctor first, not a tutor.
If no skill has gone, start with the teacher. Say what you are seeing at home, and what you have tried. Beyond the teacher, the right person depends on what it turns out to be about. If the work is too hard, someone who works on that school skill. If worry or mood is the thing, someone who works with children's mental health. In our view, if you are worried enough to ask, a professional evaluation is worth asking about.
Any talk of hurting themselves is a same-day call to your doctor or a crisis line.
In the classroom
In our view, say = out loud as "is the same as" every time.
One sentence for an email home: "Your child solved x + 4 = 9 today, but fractions tripped them up. What do you see at home?"
Key Takeaways
In our view, algebra uses earlier number work in a new way. No study we hold says why algebra gets hard for one child.
A national math panel names three things algebra is built on. They are whole numbers, fractions, and some parts of shapes and measuring. That is the panel's judgment, not a trial.
In a 2012 study (Siegler and colleagues), fraction and division knowledge predicted later algebra. That is a link, not proof that more fraction work eases algebra for one child.
The home routines on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests them at home. Do them alongside your child's math instruction, not in place of it.
In our view, ask the math teacher which step breaks. Then practice that step at home, alongside class teaching.
Our position is that a lost skill goes to a doctor first, not a tutor.
Write x + 4 = 9 on a card. Ask your child what x stands for, and how they know. Listen for the step they use. If they get stuck, get two plates. Put 4 coins and a cup on one plate. Hide 5 coins under the cup. Put 9 coins on the other plate. You are not testing anything. You are watching how they get there. This routine is ours. It is one thing to notice, not an answer on its own.
”What to do tonightWhat to use next
A set of questions you answer about what you see at home. A screener is a starting point, not a diagnosis. If your child might need formal accommodations (an IEP or 504 plan), or you suspect a vision, hearing, or medical cause, pursue a professional evaluation too โ that's the only route to those supports.
What sits underneath arithmetic, one skill at a time, worked alongside math instruction, not in place of it.
A parent course inside All Access on the layer under your child's math: where numbers sit on a line, five and ten as landmarks, breaking numbers apart, and whether an answer makes sense. Five-minute moments with things already in the house. Use it alongside math instruction, not in place of it. The activities are adapted from ones tested mostly with researchers and teachers. How well they work with a parent at the table has barely been studied, and not at all past about age seven. It comes after our parent course, Foundations.
Common questions from parents
Why is algebra so hard for my child?
In our view, algebra uses earlier number work in a new way. Letters stand for numbers. The equal sign means "the same as." Many problems take steps in order. No study we hold says why algebra gets hard for one child. A national math panel names three things algebra is built on. Whole numbers and fractions are two of them. That is the panel's judgment, not a trial. Our advice is to ask the math teacher which step breaks.
My child was fine at math and is suddenly failing algebra. Why?
We hold no study of why algebra suddenly gets hard for one child. In our view, look at which step breaks. It may be fractions, numbers below zero, the equal sign, or problems with many steps. Then ask if this is new work, or a mastered skill that has clearly gone. Our position is that a lost skill goes to a doctor first, not a tutor. If no skill has gone, start with the math teacher. Say what you see at home.
Is trouble with algebra a sign of dyscalculia?
The lists of dyscalculia signs we hold do not name algebra. Algebra trouble alone does not tell you why, in our view. In our view, tell the teacher what you see. Our free screener is a set of questions you answer about what you see at home. A screener is a starting point, not a diagnosis. If your child might need formal accommodations (an IEP or 504 plan), or you suspect a vision, hearing, or medical cause, pursue a professional evaluation too โ that's the only route to those supports.
How can I help with algebra at home?
The home routines on this page are ours. We hold no study that tests them at home. Do them alongside your child's math instruction, not in place of it. In our view, talk through a solved problem one line at a time. Then solve one problem two ways, and compare. A 2015 federal algebra guide (Star and colleagues) advises studying solved problems. It also advises comparing ways to solve. It is for all students learning algebra, in grades 6 to 12. It says comparing works best once a student can do the steps with some ease.
What does the federal algebra guide recommend?
A 2015 federal guide on algebra (Star and colleagues) gives three pieces of advice. Study solved problems. Notice how equations are built. Compare ways to solve. Its evidence for comparing ways is moderate. Its evidence for the other two is minimal. It says comparing works best once the steps come with some ease. It is for grades 6 to 12. It is for all students learning algebra. It is not a guide to dyscalculia. Nothing in the guide tests Learning Success.
More in Signs and symptoms
- Geometry Struggles and Spatial Skills
- Graphs, Charts and Data Questions
- Long Division Is a Nightmare
- Math Facts vs Math Understanding: Which Is Missing?
- My Child Can't Do Mental Math
- My Child Is Great at Reading But Terrible at Math
- Negative Numbers Don't Make Sense
- Order of Operations Keeps Going Wrong