Start Free Trial

Food Dyes, Sugar and Behavior: What the Evidence Supports

Wolraich, Wilson and White (1995) pooled studies of sugar. On average, sugar did not change how children behaved. A small effect in some children was not ruled out. Nigg and colleagues (2012) pooled studies of food colors and ADHD symptoms. Parents' ratings showed an effect. Teachers' ratings did not. The authors urged caution. Ask your child's doctor about any diet.

TL;DR

  1. Wolraich, Wilson and White (1995) pooled careful studies of sugar. In each one, no one knew which drink had sugar in it. On average, sugar did not change how children behaved. A small effect in some children was not ruled out.
  2. Hoover and Milich (1994) gave 35 boys a drink with no sugar in it. Mothers who were told it had sugar rated their sons as more hyperactive. It was one small study, of boys only. It does not explain every report from a parent.
  3. McCann and colleagues (2007) gave children juice each day. In some weeks, it had one of two mixes of food colors and a preservative. Hyperactive behavior went up in those weeks. In the younger children, that was so for one mix only. The trial tested mixes, so it cannot say which part did it. The result was a rating of behavior, not a diagnosis.
  4. Nigg and colleagues (2012) pooled studies of diets that cut out certain foods. Some children with ADHD seem to respond. No one can yet say which children. Any restricted diet should be planned with your child's doctor.
  5. Gillies, Leach and Perez Algorta (2023) reviewed fatty-acid supplements for ADHD. They found little evidence that these supplements help with ADHD. That finding is about ADHD signs that parents rated.
  6. This page covers six studies and reviews. None of these studies was about children with dyslexia or another learning difference. Two were reviews about children with ADHD.
“

Food dyes, as we use the words, are artificial colors in food and drink. Some studies call them synthetic food dyes.

”Food dyes

Does sugar make kids hyper?

Wolraich, Wilson and White (1995) pooled 23 careful studies of sugar. In each study, no one knew which drink had sugar in it. That included the children, the parents and the staff.

On average, sugar did not change how children behaved or thought. The authors could not rule out a small effect. They could not rule out an effect in some children.

So we would not tell you that sugar has no effect. We would not tell you that sugar makes children hyper, either.

Why a parent may see a change after sugar

Hoover and Milich (1994) studied 35 boys. Their mothers saw them as sensitive to sugar. Every boy had a drink with no sugar in it. Half of the mothers were told the drink had a lot of sugar.

Those mothers rated their sons as more hyperactive. It was one small study, of boys only.

It shows that what we expect can shape what we see. It does not explain every report from a parent.

Do food colors change behavior?

McCann and colleagues (2007) ran a careful trial. The children were not picked because of ADHD. Some were younger and some were older. Each day, they drank juice. In some weeks, the juice had one of two mixes. Each mix had food colors and a preservative. In other weeks, it did not. No one knew which week was which.

Hyperactive behavior went up in weeks with the additives. In the younger children, that was so for one of the two mixes. The trial tested mixes, so it cannot say which part did it. The result was a rating of behavior, not a diagnosis.

Nigg and colleagues (2012) pooled studies of food colors and ADHD symptoms. Parents' ratings showed an effect of the colors. Teachers' and observers' ratings did not. The authors said not to base advice for all children on this.

A California state office also looked at food dyes. It is the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA, 2021). It found that food dyes can affect behavior in some children. That included children with and without behavior problems. Its report weighs risk. It is not advice for doctors. It does not tell any family what to do.

The studies we hold suggest food colors can affect behavior in some children, not most. Parents noticed it more than teachers did.

Do elimination diets help ADHD?

Nigg and colleagues (2012) also pooled studies of diets that cut out certain foods.

In those studies, ADHD symptoms went down on the diets. Some children with ADHD seem to respond. No one can yet say which children. No one can say which foods, either. The authors said the evidence is too weak for a rule for all children.

Does fish oil help ADHD?

Gillies, Leach and Perez Algorta (2023) wrote a Cochrane review. It pooled 37 trials. The trials tested fatty-acid supplements, such as fish oil.

The supplements made no difference to ADHD signs that parents rated. One weak finding went the other way. The authors had little trust in it.

They found little evidence that these supplements help with ADHD.

What these studies did not look at

None of these studies was about children with dyslexia or another learning difference. Two were reviews about children with ADHD.

Food matters to children. No study we hold shows that any food causes ADHD. No study we hold makes any diet the answer to ADHD.

Sugary treats as rewards

In our view, sugary treats used as rewards can make plain tasks feel flat. That is about comparison, not about what sugar does. What we see is that plain tasks can feel harder to start after big rewards. This is our practice, not a tested result.

Questions about what your child eats

Questions about what a particular child should eat or drink are for the child's doctor or a registered dietitian. Nutrition is not something we assess or work on. Food and drink are part of the routine around schoolwork. None of it is a way to teach a skill.

Any restricted diet should be planned with your child's doctor. Do not stop anything your child's doctor advised without talking to them first.

When to ask for help

Each of these is a reason to ask for help on its own.

If no skill has gone, start with the teacher. Say what you are seeing at home, and what you have tried. Beyond the teacher, the right person depends on what it turns out to be about. If the work is too hard, someone who works on that school skill. If worry or mood is the thing, someone who works with children's mental health. In our view, delays in speech, language or movement are worth raising with your child's doctor. In our view, if you are worried enough to ask, a professional evaluation is worth asking about.

Any talk of hurting themselves is a same-day call to your doctor or a crisis line.

In the classroom

1

In our view, tell the family what you saw and when it happened. Leave food questions to the family and the child's doctor.

2

One sentence for an email home: "She found it hard to settle during math today."

Key Takeaways

1

Wolraich, Wilson and White (1995) pooled careful studies of sugar. On average, sugar did not change how children behaved. A small effect in some children was not ruled out.

2

Hoover and Milich (1994) found mothers who expected sugar saw more hyperactive behavior. The boys had had no sugar. It was one small study, of boys only. It does not explain every report from a parent.

3

Nigg and colleagues (2012) pooled studies of food colors and ADHD symptoms. Parents' ratings showed an effect of the colors. Teachers' and observers' ratings did not. The authors said not to base advice for all children on this.

4

Nigg and colleagues (2012) pooled studies of diets that cut out certain foods. Some children with ADHD seem to respond. No one can yet say which children. Any restricted diet should be planned with your child's doctor.

5

Gillies, Leach and Perez Algorta (2023) reviewed fatty-acid supplements for ADHD. They found little evidence that these supplements help with ADHD. That finding is about ADHD signs that parents rated.

6

This page covers six studies and reviews. None of these studies was about children with dyslexia or another learning difference. Two were reviews about children with ADHD.

7

Ask your child's doctor or a registered dietitian about what your child eats.

“

Tonight, notice one moment when your child found it hard to settle. Write down what came just before it. Note the task, the time and how your child slept. Bring the notes to any visit with your child's doctor. This is our practice, not a tested result.

”What to do tonight

What to use next

free

Focus Foundations

A free PDF for parents of children who are building focus.

free

Free Resources

Downloads and free programs, if you are not sure yet what you need.

membership

All Access

Every Learning Success program in one membership.

Common questions from parents

Does sugar make kids hyper?

Wolraich, Wilson and White (1995) pooled 23 careful studies of sugar. In each one, no one knew which drink had sugar in it. On average, sugar did not change how children behaved or thought. The authors could not rule out a small effect. They could not rule out an effect in some children. So we would not tell you that sugar has no effect. Ask your child's doctor about any question on diet.

Why does my child seem wild after sugar?

Hoover and Milich (1994) studied 35 boys. Their mothers saw them as sensitive to sugar. Every boy had a drink with no sugar in it. Mothers who were told it had sugar rated their sons as more hyperactive. It was one small study, of boys only. It shows that what we expect can shape what we see. It does not explain every report from a parent.

Do food coloring and dyes affect behavior?

McCann and colleagues (2007) gave children juice each day. In some weeks, it had one of two mixes of food colors and a preservative. Hyperactive behavior went up in those weeks. In the younger children, that was so for one mix only. The trial tested mixes, so it cannot say which part did it. The result was a rating of behavior, not a diagnosis. Nigg and colleagues (2012) found that parents saw an effect of food colors. Teachers did not. Neither did observers. The authors said not to base advice for all children on this. Ask your child's doctor about any change in diet.

Does an elimination diet help ADHD?

Nigg and colleagues (2012) pooled studies of diets that cut out certain foods. Some children with ADHD seem to respond. No one can yet say which children. No one can say which foods, either. The authors said the evidence is too weak for a rule for all children. Any restricted diet should be planned with your child's doctor. Do not stop anything your child's doctor advised without talking to them first.

Does fish oil help ADHD?

Gillies, Leach and Perez Algorta (2023) wrote a Cochrane review. It pooled 37 trials of fatty-acid supplements, such as fish oil. The supplements made no difference to ADHD signs that parents rated. One weak finding went the other way. The authors had little trust in it. They found little evidence that these help with ADHD. Ask your child's doctor about any supplement.

Start Building Real Skills Today

One membership, every program, no upgrade path.

All Access includes every Learning Success program. You're never one more purchase away from the thing your child needs.

More in Sleep and screens