The Middle-School Cliff: When Grades Drop After Elementary School
Apart from two studies of reading, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of grades dropping after the move to middle school. In our view, find out first whether work is missing or wrong. Start with one class. Ask that teacher what is missing, what is late and what is hard.
TL;DR
- Apart from two studies of reading, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of grades dropping after the move to middle school.
- In our view, find out first whether work is missing or wrong.
- In our view, start with one class, not all of them. Ask that teacher what is missing, what is late and what is hard.
- In our view, ask your child which class feels hardest. Listen to the whole answer.
- Some children read well enough early on and fall behind later. This falling behind came around grades 3 to 4 or after. Two US studies found such children (Catts and colleagues, 2012; Leach and colleagues, 2003). Neither study was about the move to middle school. We cannot tell you whether your child is one of these children.
- For worry, ask a mental-health professional.
Middle-school cliff. As we use the words, this is a sudden drop in schoolwork. It comes after the move to middle school.
”Middle-school cliffOur own ideas for a sudden drop
Apart from two studies of reading, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of grades dropping after the move to middle school. That is a gap in what we hold, not a finding either way. Use the ideas as you like.
This page gives no age rules for executive function. Our page on executive function by age has more.
Why did the grades drop?
We cannot tell you why grades dropped for your child.
In our view, find out first whether work is missing or wrong. Start with the teacher.
Missing or wrong?
In our view, find out first whether work is missing or wrong. As we use the words, missing work was not handed in. Wrong work was handed in, but it has mistakes.
In our view, each one points to a different next step.
In our view, if work is missing, look at how it gets handed in. Our page on organization systems has more.
In our view, if work is wrong, look at which skill is hard. Ask the teacher which part.
Look at what changed this year
In our view, look at what changed this year. Ask yourself:
- How many teachers does your child have now?
- How is homework given out and handed in?
- Where can you see grades and missing work?
- What does your child carry from class to class?
Start with one class
These ideas are ours. We hold no study that names them.
- Ask your child. Ask which class feels hardest. Ask which part of it.
- Pick one class. Start there, not with all of them.
- Ask that teacher three things. What is missing? What is late? What is hard?
- Write it down. Write down what the teacher says.
- Agree on a next step. If you and the teacher agree to try something, write down what it is. Agree on a date to check back. Then check back on that date.
Our page on letter templates has an email to the teacher.
What two studies of reading found
Some children read well enough early on and fall behind later. This falling behind came around grades 3 to 4 or after. Two US studies found such children (Catts and colleagues, 2012; Leach and colleagues, 2003). Neither study was about the move to middle school. We cannot tell you whether your child is one of these children. Our page on reading trouble that shows up later has more.
Talk with your child
In our view, sit down together. Ask what feels hardest. Listen to the whole answer.
For worry, ask a mental-health professional.
A course for the parent's side
Foundations, our parent course in All Access, trains the parent who sits beside the child, one skill a week. We hold no study of the course itself.
When to ask for help
Some children could do something and now cannot. Our position is that a lost skill goes to a doctor first, not a tutor.
If no skill has gone, start with the teacher. Say what you are seeing at home, and what you have tried. Beyond the teacher, the right person depends on what it turns out to be about. If the work is too hard, someone who works on that school skill. If worry or mood is the thing, someone who works with children's mental health.
Any talk of hurting themselves is a same-day call to your doctor or a crisis line.
Tonight, ask your child which class feels hardest. Write down what they say. This idea is ours. We hold no study of it.
”What to do tonightWhat to use next
Our parent course, inside All Access. It trains you, the parent beside your child, in six skills from martial-arts teaching, one a week. Each week has a short video, a small drill for you and one exercise with your child. Your child never watches a video.
Common questions from parents
Why did my child's grades drop in middle school?
Apart from two studies of reading, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of grades dropping after the move to middle school. We cannot tell you why grades dropped for your child. In our view, find out first whether work is missing or wrong. Start with the teacher.
My child has been struggling since starting middle school. What do I do?
Apart from two studies of reading, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of grades dropping after the move to middle school. In our view, start with one class, not all of them. Ask your child which class feels hardest. Ask that teacher what is missing, what is late and what is hard.
Will my child settle in on their own?
Apart from two studies of reading, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of grades dropping after the move to middle school. We cannot tell you whether your child will settle in on their own. In our view, talk to the teacher now rather than wait.
More in Executive function
- Chores as Executive Function Practice
- Executive Function by Age: What's Reasonable to Expect
- Executive Function in Plain English
- Organization: Systems That Survive Real Children
- Scaffolding vs Rescuing: How Much Help Is Too Much
- Self-Monitoring: Catching Your Own Mistakes
- Time Management for Children Who Have No Sense of Time