Homework Contracts and Agreements That Hold
Apart from one review by Patall's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of homework contracts or written homework agreements. In our view, keep the contract short. Write it together at a calm time. Say when and where homework happens, and what help looks like. Leave out rewards and punishments.
TL;DR
- Apart from one review by Patall's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of homework contracts or written homework agreements.
- Patall, Cooper and Robinson (2008) pooled studies of parents and homework. In a small set of them, clear rules about when and where homework happens went with better results. Simply checking up on a child did not go with better results. Those are links, not tests. It is a pattern in a few studies, not a rule.
- In our view, a contract is one way to write homework rules down.
- In our view, keep a homework contract short. Write it together at a calm time. Say when and where homework happens. Say what comes first, and what help looks like.
- In our view, leave out rewards and punishments. After a bad night, try again tomorrow.
Homework contract. As we use the words, a homework contract is a short written plan. You and your child agree on it.
”Homework contractOur own ideas for a homework contract
Apart from one review by Patall's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of homework contracts or written homework agreements. That is a gap in what we hold, not a finding either way. Use the ideas as you like.
In our view, a fixed rule is easier to keep than a new argument each night. In our view, a plan your child helped set is easier to keep.
What a review of homework studies found
Patall, Cooper and Robinson (2008) pooled studies of parents and homework. In a small set of them, clear rules about when and where homework happens went with better results. Simply checking up on a child did not go with better results. Those are links, not tests. It is a pattern in a few studies, not a rule.
In our view, a contract is one way to write rules like those down.
What to put in it
The first idea is close to the rules in that review. The rest are ours. We hold no study that names them.
- When and where. Pick a time and a place for homework. Our page on the time of day for homework has more.
- The first piece. Say what your child does first. Make it small enough to finish. Four problems, not the sheet.
- How it ends. Say how you both know the work is done.
- What help looks like. Say what you will do to help. Say how your child can ask for it.
- A bad night. Say what happens when it goes wrong. In our view, that is a calm try again tomorrow. It is not a punishment.
- Your names. You can both sign it, if your child likes that.
A sample contract
Here is one way it could look. Change any line to fit your family.
- Homework happens at the kitchen table, after a snack.
- We start with one small piece.
- When I am stuck, I say, "Can you help me with this one?"
- My grown-up sits nearby and helps when I ask.
- We take a short break between pieces.
- If a night goes badly, nobody is in trouble. We try again tomorrow.
- We look at this plan again soon. We can change one line.
- Signed: _ and _
How to write it together
Pick a calm time. In our view, write it when things are calm, not right after a fight.
Keep it short. In our view, a few lines on one page is enough.
Use your child's words. In our view, let your child say some of the lines. Write them down the way your child says them.
Look at it again. In our view, read it together after a week or two. Change one line if a line is not working.
Tell the teacher about long nights. If the work often takes far longer than the teacher intended, tell the teacher.
Our page on how long homework should take has more.
What to leave out
Rewards. In our view, leave rewards out. That means no points, no stickers and no screen time as payment. Our page on the homework battle has more.
Checking up. In our view, the plan is not a way to watch over your child.
Blame. In our view, the plan should never shame your child for a slip.
A course for the parent's side
We also built a course for the parent's side of homework. Foundations, our parent course in All Access, trains the parent who sits beside the child, one skill a week. We hold no study of the course itself.
When to ask for help
Some things are reasons to get another pair of eyes on it.
- Real distress about any homework at all.
- Work that takes far longer than the teacher intended.
- A child who seems unable to feel any satisfaction from schoolwork, in any setting, over weeks, not days.
- A fight that is damaging the way your family gets along.
They are reasons to ask, not a category to sort a child into.
Some children could do something and now cannot. Our position is that a lost skill goes to a doctor first, not a tutor.
If no skill has gone, start with the teacher. Say what you are seeing at home, and what you have tried.
Any talk of hurting themselves is a same-day call to your doctor or a crisis line.
Find a calm time with your child. Write three lines together. One says when and where homework happens. One says what the first piece is. One says how to ask for help. This idea is ours. We hold no study of it.
”What to do tonightWhat to use next
Our parent course, inside All Access. It trains you, the parent beside your child, in six skills from martial-arts teaching, one a week. Each week has a short video, a small drill for you and one exercise with your child. Your child never watches a video.
Common questions from parents
What goes in a homework contract?
Apart from one review by Patall's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of homework contracts or written homework agreements. In our view, a few lines are enough. Say when and where homework happens. Say what the first piece is, and how the work ends. Say how your child can ask for help. Say what happens after a bad night. In our view, that is a calm try again tomorrow.
Should a homework contract have rewards?
Apart from one review by Patall's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of homework contracts or written homework agreements. In our view, leave rewards out. That means no points, no stickers and no screen time as payment.
Do homework rules help?
Apart from one review by Patall's team, the ideas on this page are ours. We hold no study of homework contracts or written homework agreements. Patall, Cooper and Robinson (2008) pooled studies of parents and homework. In a small set of them, clear rules about when and where homework happens went with better results. Simply checking up on a child did not go with better results. Those are links, not tests. It is a pattern in a few studies, not a rule. So we do not know if a contract helps. In our view, it is one way to write rules like those down.