Parent at a sunny kitchen table looking at a hand-drawn progress line on graph paper

My Child Has Had Years of Tutoring and Still Struggles to Read or Spell. Why Isn’t It Working, and What Do I Do Now?

In 2015, Scammacca and colleagues pooled three decades of studies on older struggling readers. Their summary of what progress looks like at that stage: “slow but steady.”

After years of tutoring, that line cuts two ways. Slow is normal, and flat is not. Your child isn’t broken; their brain is learning differently. The real question is whether anyone has been checking which kind of progress you are looking at.

TL;DR

  1. Hours of tutoring are not a measure of progress. Before you doubt your child, check the tutoring: what is taught, how spelling is taught, and whether anyone charts growth.
  2. For an older child, real progress is “slow but steady” (Scammacca and colleagues, 2015). A line that rises slowly is working. A line that stays flat check after check means the teaching has to change.
  3. Tonight, start one home measure: a short list of words your child reads aloud and spells from memory. Use the same list each month and chart the results.
“

Slow is normal. Flat is not. The only way to tell them apart is to measure.

“– Laura Lurns

Why years of sessions stall: hours without a measure

Tutoring is sold by the hour. Hours are easy to count, so they start to feel like progress. But an hour of homework help and an hour of direct teaching are not the same hour. And a report that says “she’s doing great in sessions” tells you how the session felt, not whether reading grew. That is true whether or not anyone has put the word dyslexia on your child’s struggle.

So what should the time hold? For older readers, there is a 2022 What Works Clearinghouse practice guide for grades 4 to 9, by Vaughn and colleagues. Two of the practices it gives a strong evidence rating are decoding long, multisyllabic words, and purposeful fluency practice. Its steps start by finding out where the student is, with a list of regular and irregular words. They use one routine for breaking long words apart. And they say to spell the words too. The studies behind the guide were run in schools, five days a week, for a semester or longer, and the gains were modest. It is a guide for older struggling readers in general, not a dyslexia guide.

For a younger child, there is a What Works Clearinghouse guide for kindergarten to third grade (Foorman and colleagues, 2016). It gives a strong rating to linking sounds to letters, and to teaching children to decode, spell and recognize words.

Now picture the moment your child gets stuck on a word. If the prompt is “look at the picture” or “what would make sense here?”, your child is being taught to guess. Eye-tracking studies by Rayner found that skilled readers look at most words in turn. Guessing is not how strong readers read.

Practice per word matters too. In one older study, Ehri and Saltmarsh (1995) found that older struggling readers needed more tries to learn new words by sight. That is one reason we look at how many times a word gets practiced, not how many hours are on the clock.

The myth: if phonics is taught, spelling will follow

Phonics is necessary. It is the sound route into a written word, and your child needs it. But spelling asks for something the sound route alone does not give. Say their and there out loud. They sound the same, so the sounds do not tell your child which letters to write. For words like these, and for words that break the usual patterns, your child has to remember the whole word.

Niolaki and colleagues (2023) tested 641 children. Whole-word measures predicted spelling accuracy better than sound-based measures, at every age they looked at. That is not a reason to teach less phonics. It is a reason to teach spelling as its own job, with its own practice.

How spelling is practiced matters too. Jones and colleagues (2016) ran three small experiments with first and second graders. Writing a word from memory, then checking it, worked better than copying it. The studies were small, so treat this as a direction, not a measured size.

The last piece is the measure. The National Center on Intensive Intervention describes a cycle for children who are not responding to help. Use a well-supported program. Track progress with the same short measure. Look closer when the line is flat, change the teaching, then track again. Scammacca and colleagues wrote that these difficulties “likely do require many hours of intervention to remediate,” so hours are part of the help. Hours alone are not a plan, though.

Set your expectations honestly, too. In one small trial, Vaughn and colleagues (2012) gave eighth graders who had not responded to two earlier years of help a third year of intensive intervention. They gained in word reading and comprehension compared with a comparison group. Even so, the authors note that “most continued to lack grade-level proficiency” after that third year. Growth that has not closed the gap is still growth, and in that trial it put them ahead of the comparison group. You’ll find more in our summary of the reading research.

Child reading aloud from a page while a parent listens beside them with a notebook
Laura LurnsEducation Expert

When a parent tells me about years of tutoring, I ask for two things: a look at a real session and a chart. In the session, I listen for what happens when the child hits a hard word. Is the child sounding it out, or being told to guess? On the chart, I look for a line. Once the teaching is direct and the same list gets checked each month, the conversation changes. Parents stop asking whether the tutor is nice and start asking whether the line is rising.

Years of tutoring and your child still struggles to read or spell? Ask the tutor for a chart this week. Slow but steady is progress. A flat line means the teaching has to change.

Tweet This

Key Takeaways

1

Hours of tutoring are not a measure of progress. Ask what is taught, how spelling is taught, and to see a chart of growth.

2

Spelling needs its own practice. The sounds of their and there do not say which letters to write, so whole words have to be remembered, written from memory and checked.

3

For an older reader, progress is “slow but steady” (Scammacca and colleagues, 2015). A slow rise is working. A flat line means change the teaching, not only the hours.

“

Nobody will ever advocate for your child as hard as you will. Asking to see the chart is part of that.

“– Laura Lurns

What to do this week: four questions for the tutor, one list for tonight

You do not have to fire anyone this week. You need answers. Send the tutor an email, or ask for ten minutes at the end of a session, and put these four questions to them.

1. What does a session spend its time on? Ask how much is direct teaching of word reading and spelling, in a planned order, and how much is homework help. Then ask what the tutor says when your child is stuck on a word. Sounding it out is teaching. “Look at the picture” is guessing.

2. How is spelling taught? Ask whether spelling has its own practice, with words written from memory and then checked, not only copied or read.

3. What do you measure, and where is the chart? Ask for the same short measure, repeated over time, with the results drawn as a line. A report on how sessions feel is not a measure.

4. When the line went flat, what changed? If the answer is only “we added hours,” ask what the tutor looked at more closely and what they changed in the teaching.

If your child also gets reading support at school, ask the school for its progress data too. Put the two side by side.

Tonight, start your own measure. Pick twenty words: some that follow common spelling patterns and some that break them, like said, their and through. Have your child read the list aloud. Then say ten of the words, one at a time, and have your child spell them from memory. Count what is right, write the date, and put the list away. Do not practice it. Use the same list next month, and the month after. You are looking for the direction of the line, not a jump.

You want a child who reads a page without dread, and you have paid for it in money and in evenings. Our view is that the villain here is a system, not a tutor. Help gets sold by the hour with no growth measure attached, and children get labeled instead of helped. You are the one who asks for the chart. Nobody will ever advocate for your child as hard as you will.

When reading is hard, we look at more than reading. The sounds, the page, holding words in mind. Our assessment asks about all of them. Start with All Access here.

Is Your Child Struggling in School?

Get your free personalized learning roadmap.

You describe what you see at home. We turn it into a plan you start this week. Learning Success has spent fifteen years helping parents do exactly that.

You answer 5 short questionnaires about what you already notice, in 30 to 45 minutes at your own kitchen table. Your child sits no test and gets no score, so there is nothing to schedule and nothing for them to dread. You do the answering, the AI does the writing, and a person reviews it before it reaches you. Your trial opens all 40+ courses right away: reading, math, focus, processing and more.

Why we use AI, plainly: it writes from a knowledge base our team maintains and audits. We work through it line by line and pull anything the evidence stops supporting. Doing that by hand for every family would take weeks each time. This way the roadmap you get on Tuesday reflects what we corrected on Monday, and a human still reads it before you do.

Your answers stay yours. We do not sell your personal information, and we do not hand identifiable assessment data to outside AI companies to train their models.

Your school district must evaluate your child free of charge if you ask in writing, whatever your income and whatever the outcome (US, 34 CFR 300.111 and 300.301(b)). That route takes time and it answers a different question than this one does. A screener is a starting point, not a diagnosis. If your child might need formal accommodations such as an IEP or 504 plan, or you suspect a vision, hearing or medical cause, pursue a professional evaluation as well. That is the only route to those supports.

Common questions from parents

How do I know if my child’s reading tutoring is working?

Ask for a measure, not a feeling. The same short check, repeated over time and charted, should show a line that rises, even slowly. If the line has stayed flat check after check, the teaching needs to change.

How long should it take to see progress from tutoring?

No honest answer comes as a number of weeks. Looking at older struggling readers, Scammacca and colleagues (2015) called progress “slow but steady” at this stage. So judge the direction of the line over several checks, not the size of one jump.

Should we add more tutoring hours?

Hours matter for older readers. These difficulties “likely do require many hours of intervention to remediate,” wrote Scammacca and colleagues (2015). But when progress is flat, the National Center on Intensive Intervention describes looking closer, changing the teaching, then measuring again. More of the same is not a change.

Why does my child read words they still misspell?

Reading and spelling ask for different things. To read their, your child has the letters in front of them. To spell it, your child has to recall which letters, and the sounds alone do not say. That is why spelling needs its own practice, written from memory and checked.

Should I switch tutors?

Ask the four questions first. A tutor who teaches word reading and spelling directly, measures growth and changes course when the line is flat is worth keeping. If you get no clear answers, that is your answer.

Scroll to Top